‹/› Devsworld News

Devsworld Home

Google Wins API Lawsuit Against Oracle

By Paula Bernier
June 01, 2016

What constitutes unfair copying? This question comes up again and again in debates related to a variety of industries, and the software space is no exception. But, interestingly, a recent lawsuit involving tech giants Google and Oracle focused on application programming interfaces, which need to have some commonality with the software programs with which they interface to work, making the whole debate a bit hairier.

Here’s the story.

Several years ago Google wanted Java-based programs to run on its Android operating system. It talked with Java creator Sun Microsystems about how they could work together to make that happen, but as Vox Technology reported here, those talks broke down. So Google went ahead and built APIs that didn’t reuse Java code, but did leverage some of the same names and functionality found in Java software.

Oracle, which later bought Sun Microsystems, sued Google in 2010 over the APIs. U.S. District Judge William Alsup in 2012 ruled that APIs can’t be copyrighted; however, that opinion was overturned on appeal.

But the fight raged on.

Following a two-week trial just last month, a federal jury on Thursday unanimously ruled that Google’s Android OS does not infringe on Oracle-owned copyrights because its reimplementation of 37 Java APIs is protected by fair use. Oracle, which may have asked for as much as $9 billion had it won the lawsuit, said it plans to appeal.

This fair use conclusion was backed up by Google’s references during the trial of a 1995 ruling concluding that Borland didn’t not infringe on copyright in creating a spreadsheet programs with menus organizations like those in Lotus 1-2-3.

Recent reporting by Vox Technology added to that by noting the “long tradition of computer programs being designed to be compatible with other programs created by third parties.” Open source project Samba, which allows Linux users to share files with Windows users, is one such example and is widely accepted as legal, according to the report.

The ruling in Google’s favor is viewed as a win for software developers, according to several sources.

“Google’s win somewhat softens the blow to software developers who previously thought programming language APIs were free to use,” reported Arstechnica. “It’s still the case that APIs can be protected by copyright under the law of at least one appeals court. However, the first high-profile attempt to control APIs with copyright law has now been stymied by a fair use defense.”

IDC analyst Al Hilwa agreed, but noted that this ruling sets a high bar for creativity before deserving protection from fair use.

“APIs are used pervasively in software for interoperability, and so most developers would likely prefer not to be burdened by copyrights around APIs,” Hilwa added. “Also, when you look at the shift that is taking place towards open source, you can say that the licensing of copyrights overall, in the world of developer platforms and tools, has trended towards more permissive licensing. Still many companies and developers want to be free to protect their creativity in any manner they wish. I think this is a situation where Oracle feels deeply that it has been wronged and has pursued every approach possible to get remedy. I think protection through APIs was not their first choice in seeking remedy.”

To learn more about this important topic, join us at the upcoming All About the API event. It will take place July 18 through 21 at Caesars Palace in Las Vegas.

Edited by Stefania Viscusi

Executive Editor, TMC

Related Articles

Telecom API Market Set for Big Gains

By: Steve Anderson    3/24/2017

A rapidly increasing need for APIs and similar measures is expected to drive big gains in this market through 2021.

Read More

Flowroute to Discuss Common API Mistakes at All About the API

By: Alicia Young    2/8/2017

Doug Waller of Flowroute will be taking part in a panel at the All About The API event, collocated with ITEXPO, to discuss common mistakes that occur …

Read More

Wear Your Lifestyle with Google's Awareness API

By: Alicia Young    2/8/2017

Google has teamed up with H&M's digital fashion house Ivyrevel to use its Awareness API in a unique way. The duo wants to digitally design customized …

Read More

10 Trends that Will Impact Open-Source Technology

By: Special Guest    2/8/2017

Open source has become an integral piece of every developer's arsenal. The power of the community, the wisdom of many, and the ability to hook into va…

Read More

What the Google Hangouts API Shutdown Means

By: Special Guest    2/6/2017

Google's in an interesting place with Hangouts and chat with both the enterprise and the consumer. One thing is clear - what it's doing with Hangouts …

Read More